Peer Review Process and Policy

METHOMIKA | EDITORIAL POLICY

Peer Review Process and Policy

Ensuring fairness, scientific integrity, confidentiality, and rigorous evaluation of scholarly manuscripts.

Peer Review Policy

METHOMIKA: Jurnal Manajemen Informatika & Komputerisasi Akuntansi is committed to maintaining high standards of scientific quality, academic integrity, objectivity, and transparency in scholarly publishing.

All manuscripts submitted to the journal undergo an initial editorial screening followed by a Double-Blind Peer Review process involving three reviewers. Reviewers evaluate manuscripts based on scientific originality, relevance, methodological rigor, analytical quality, clarity, and contribution to knowledge.

Peer Review at a Glance

Review Model Double-Blind Peer Review
Number of Reviewers Three reviewers
Initial Editorial Screening Approximately one week
Peer Review Period Approximately 2-4 weeks
Author Revision Period Approximately 1-2 weeks
Similarity Requirement Below 20%

The indicated timelines are estimates and may vary depending on reviewer availability, manuscript complexity, and revision requirements.

Stages of the Peer Review Process

1. Manuscript Submission

Authors submit manuscripts through the journal's Open Journal Systems (OJS) platform. Submissions must comply with the journal's Focus and Scope, Author Guidelines, manuscript template, and publication policies. Authors must provide complete and accurate manuscript metadata.

2. Similarity Screening

Submitted manuscripts are screened using similarity detection software. Manuscripts must comply with the journal's similarity threshold of below 20%. The editorial team also examines potential plagiarism, duplicate publication, and inappropriate citation practices. Similarity percentages are interpreted in the context of the manuscript content.

3. Initial Editorial Screening

The editorial team conducts an initial assessment within approximately one week. This assessment evaluates the manuscript's relevance to the journal, completeness, originality, formatting, scientific presentation, and compliance with submission requirements. Manuscripts that do not meet the requirements may be returned for correction or declined before external peer review.

4. Reviewer Assignment

Manuscripts passing the initial screening are assigned to three reviewers selected by the editorial team from the journal's reviewer pool. Reviewer selection considers the relevance of expertise, availability, independence, and potential conflicts of interest.

5. Double-Blind Peer Review

METHOMIKA applies a Double-Blind Peer Review model in which reviewer identities are concealed from authors and author identities are concealed from reviewers. Reviewers independently assess the manuscript and provide constructive comments and recommendations. The review period is generally scheduled for approximately 2-4 weeks.

6. Editorial Decision

The editorial team evaluates reviewer reports, scientific quality, ethical compliance, and the manuscript's relevance before making an editorial decision. Decisions may include acceptance, revision requests, or rejection. Reviewer recommendations inform the decision but do not automatically determine it.

7. Manuscript Revision

Authors receiving a revision decision are generally given 1-2 weeks to revise their manuscripts and upload the revised files through OJS. Authors should respond to reviewer comments systematically and provide explanations for substantial changes or recommendations that are not adopted. Additional review may be requested when necessary.

8. Final Acceptance and Copyediting

Manuscripts meeting the journal's scientific and editorial requirements may receive a final acceptance decision. Accepted manuscripts proceed to copyediting, during which the editorial team checks language consistency, formatting, references, and publication readiness. The Journal Manager issues the Letter of Acceptance (LoA) through the OJS platform at the copyediting stage.

9. Production and Publication

Accepted and copyedited manuscripts proceed to production, including final layout preparation, proofreading, metadata verification, and publication scheduling. The final publication schedule is determined by the editorial team. Acceptance does not guarantee publication in a particular issue.

Manuscript Evaluation Criteria

Reviewers are expected to assess manuscripts according to the following criteria:

  • Relevance: Alignment with the journal's Focus and Scope.
  • Originality: Novelty and identifiable contribution to existing knowledge.
  • Research Problem: Clarity of objectives, motivation, and research questions.
  • Methodology: Appropriateness, transparency, validity, and reproducibility.
  • Results: Accuracy, completeness, and adequacy of supporting evidence.
  • Discussion: Critical interpretation and comparison with previous studies.
  • Conclusion: Consistency with research objectives and findings.
  • References: Relevance, accuracy, quality, and adequacy of cited literature.
  • Presentation: Academic writing, organization, tables, figures, and clarity.
  • Ethical Compliance: Research integrity and adherence to publication ethics.

Editorial Decisions

Decision Description
Accept Submission The manuscript meets publication requirements without substantive revision.
Revisions Required The manuscript requires improvements before an acceptance decision can be made.
Resubmit for Review Substantial revisions and further evaluation are required before reconsideration.
Decline Submission The manuscript does not meet the journal's scientific or editorial requirements.

Confidentiality and Reviewer Anonymity

Manuscripts under review are confidential documents. Editors and reviewers must not disclose, distribute, or use unpublished information obtained through the peer review process for personal or professional advantage.

Authors are expected to submit anonymized manuscripts for double-blind review, removing author-identifying information from the review file and document metadata where appropriate. Author identities and affiliations must remain complete in the confidential OJS submission metadata.

Reviewer identities must not be disclosed without authorization. The editorial team is responsible for maintaining confidentiality throughout the review process.

Conflicts of Interest and Reviewer Responsibilities

Reviewers must disclose any actual or potential conflict of interest that could affect their independence or objectivity. Reviewers should decline assignments when impartial assessment cannot be ensured.

Reviewers are expected to:

  • Accept review assignments only when they possess appropriate expertise.
  • Provide objective, constructive, evidence-based feedback.
  • Maintain confidentiality and respect author anonymity.
  • Complete reviews within the agreed schedule.
  • Identify relevant omissions, unsupported claims, and methodological weaknesses.
  • Notify editors of suspected plagiarism or research misconduct.
  • Avoid personal criticism, discriminatory comments, and inappropriate citation requests.
  • Refrain from uploading confidential manuscripts to unauthorized AI tools or external services.

Editorial Independence and Final Decision

Editorial decisions are based on the scientific merit of the manuscript, its relevance to the journal, reviewer recommendations, methodological quality, and compliance with publication ethics.

The Journal Manager, acting within the journal's established editorial authority, determines publication scheduling and final publication arrangements. Reviewer recommendations serve as important inputs but do not constitute automatic acceptance or rejection. Editors with conflicts of interest must not participate in decisions concerning the affected manuscripts.

Appeals and Complaints

Authors who believe that an editorial decision involves a procedural error or a substantial misunderstanding may submit a reasoned appeal to the editorial office through OJS or the journal's official communication channels.

Appeals should identify the manuscript, explain the grounds for reconsideration, and provide supporting information. Appeals will be evaluated according to editorial policy, available evidence, and applicable research ethics principles. Submission of an appeal does not guarantee a change in the editorial decision.

Full English Peer Review Policy

Effective from Volume 11, Number 1 (April 2027), all manuscripts intended for publication in METHOMIKA must be written entirely in English. Editorial correspondence, reviewer reports, author responses, manuscript revisions, and scholarly discussions throughout the peer review and publication processes must also be conducted in English.

METHOMIKA: Jurnal Manajemen Informatika & Komputerisasi Akuntansi
Published by Universitas Methodist Indonesia
Publication Frequency: April and October
Official Journal Website